Probably Stolen Haggling Guide: Discounts, Markups, Reputation
Use the bargain panel on both sides of the counter: what each of the four offers does to the price, the buyer's budget and your faction reputation.
Where do you negotiate?
The bargain panel sits beside the trade window while a deal is open. It applies to the current customer only, in the current direction: selling to a buyer and buying from a seller are two different negotiations with different costs. A refused offer does not stop you from accepting the original terms if the customer is still at the counter.
Both sides of the counter use the same panel. What changes is who is giving ground: on a sale you can charge less or ask for more, and on a purchase you can pay more or ask for less.
What are the four offers?
| Your move | Price | Acceptance | Reputation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sale: give a discount | You take less | Always accepted | Gain, plus a larger buyer budget |
| Sale: raise the price | You take more | May be refused, or the customer leaves | Spent on a completed sale |
| Purchase: offer more | You pay more | Always accepted | Gain |
| Purchase: ask for a discount | You pay less | May be refused | Spent on a completed purchase |
The first and third rows are the safe ones: neither offer can be refused. Only the sale-side concession also raises the buyer’s budget, which matters when the item you want to sell costs more than they walked in with; paying over the asking price on a purchase earns reputation and nothing else. The second row is the one that can cost you the sale: if the buyer walks out rather than settle, the goods stay on your shelf. The fourth row asks for a lower price, so an acceptance saves credits and a refusal leaves you buying at the asking price.
Why is a discount worth more than the credits?
Reputation is the currency that unlocks supplier access, better buyers and faction services, and a discount is the cheapest way to buy it. A small concession costs a slice of one sale; a markup on the same deal spends reputation instead of earning it.
The panel shows the chance of acceptance, refusal or the customer leaving, and the reputation effect per 1,000 credits of trade, so a 5% discount on a cheap item and a 5% discount on a rifle are not shown as the same transaction. The faction guide covers what each track unlocks.
Do variety buyers and tourists pay more?
Some visitors pay a price bonus on top of the ordinary offer: variety buyers and tourists. Since 1.0.0.12 that bonus counts for items already on the counter when they arrive, not only for goods placed after the customer walks in.
The bonus comes from the visitor, not from the bargain panel. A discount is your own concession, and it is the lever that raises the buyer’s budget. The customer budget table lists each buyer type’s opening budget, and the display case guide covers who the window pulls in.
When does a markup pay?
When the margin you gain outweighs the customers you lose. A refusal is not a lost sale: if the buyer stays at the counter you can still close at the original terms, so the real cost is the chance they walk out instead. Compare the leave chance the panel shows with the markup you are asking for, and check the customer budget table for what that buyer type can reach in the first place.
Markups are also how you spend reputation you no longer need. If a faction has already granted what you wanted from it, an occasional squeeze on a stranger costs less than it would with a faction you are courting. Harder difficulties multiply reputation losses, so the same markup is more expensive on Thin Margins and Red Ink.
How do you use an inspection to lower a price?
A correct challenge brings the price down to what the item is actually worth, which is the Good Inspection Discount. The condition is evidence: a counterfeit mark, a label that does not match the contents, or damage the seller did not mention. Inspect the item first, then confront.
A wrong accusation costs reputation and does not move the price, and each item allows one confrontation, so name the fault you actually found rather than the first one you suspect. The appraisal guide covers what to look for, and the display case guide covers which buyers are worth the discount in the first place.
When should you stop negotiating?
Stop when the next offer would cost more than the deal is worth. Three signals settle it:
- The leave chance is climbing and the item is scarce.
- The reputation preview is larger than the margin you are chasing.
- The customer has a fixed need, and no price will make them take a category they did not ask for.
Blackmail and Threaten sit outside ordinary haggling. They are separate options with their own penalties, they can end the interaction outright, and a failed attempt against an innocent customer is a reputation loss with nothing to show for it. Keep them for a seller you have already caught lying.
Related Articles
guides
Probably Stolen Best Starting Perks: What Each Point Buys
Compare Probably Stolen starting perks by point cost: which picks pay for themselves, which drawbacks return points, and which fit a water or security run.
guides
Probably Stolen Addicts, Spiking and Poisoning Guide
Sell Phanta and Dream Dust to create returning addicts, spike water without killing the buyer, and compare the euphoria chance against the toxicity penalty.
guides
Probably Stolen Gene Modding Guide: DNA Manipulator and Seed Traits
Unlock gene modding in Probably Stolen, run the DNA Manipulator on seeds, manage complexity and heat, and keep the donor seed with a Genetic Stabilizer Module.
Was this helpful?
Thanks for the feedback!